We Tested Over 130 Cookware Sets—But These 4 Are Our Favorites

We Tested Over 130 Cookware Sets—But These 4 Are Our Favorites

You can get away with only owning a pot and a skillet, but for most people, you’ll need a full array of cookware to get by in life. When you’re searching for the best cookware to outfit your kitchen, there are some advantages to buying a complete set. First, a set can be less expensive than buying individual pieces, so you’ll save money. Second, different cookware materials can behave differently on the stove, but when all your cookware is the same, you’ll be familiar with how they heat up and respond to temperature changes.

To help us determine the best, we’ve seared, cooked, sautéd, and more on the top-rated cookware sets, some of them multiple times, to see how well they really perform.
How We Tested Cookware Sets
Over the past two years, our Lab’s dedicated test kitchen has tested 131 sets, including stainless steel, ceramic, and nonstick cookware. We put each set through its paces, using the pots and pans for a variety of everyday tasks. In the first half of 2023, we re-evaluated our previous selections, while also testing newly released models and additional categories. We stand by our current recommendations and will continue to try out new cookware sets as they are released. We’ve also tested some sets long-term in the kitchens of our experienced at-home testers.

We Observed
How evenly the pans heated: A cookware’s build can lead to evenly cooked meals or half-burnt dinners. How quickly and evenly a pan distributes heat is, time and time again, our most important factor. After recording a pan’s surface temperature with an infrared thermometer, we fried eggs, made omelets, and browned butter to check for hot spots. We also assessed how the material and internal cladding conducted heat.
How easy they were to maneuver when full of food: We know that if a skillet is uncomfortable move around the cooktop or if a pot gets too heavy when filled with water, it goes to the back of the cupboard. We found that the balance of a pan and overall weight is another incredibly important factor.
How useful were all the pieces: Will you have all the pans you need for a full meal? If not, are there more options readily available from the same cookware line? We analyze the array of sizes in each set, and how well the pots and pans available will work in a home kitchen.
We Rated
Heating Ability and Performance: We looked over how evenly food cooked and how well the cookware maintained heat during our tests. Those with well-cooked, but not scorched, meals that didn’t need constant fiddling with on the burner received higher ratings from us.
Durability: Will a pan warp or a coating be damaged if put into an oven or, if applicable, a dishwasher? Can the cookware survive an accidental drop? Cookware that survived all three tests flawlessly is worthy of a 5 out of 5.
Design and Ease of Cleaning: Was every piece in a set incredibly comfortable and thoughtfully designed? Did the handles get hot? Did we only need to wipe with a sponge and soapy water? If we could answer yes to these questions, a set was awarded higher ratings.

 

 

Best Overall

Tramontina Tri-Ply Clad 10-Piece Set

Tramontina Tri-Ply Clad 10-Piece Stainless Steel Set
What We Like
  • Great performance when searing and browning
  • Durable and well-built
  • Affordable price
  • Lifetime warranty
What We Don’t Like
  • Some might find pots unbalanced
  • Pieces don’t stack together nicely

This Tramontina cookware set proves that you can get amazingly great pots and pans for an affordable price. Made from 18/10 stainless steel, each piece has an aluminum core that distributes the heat evenly, and they’re all magnetic so you can use them on any induction cooktop. We’ve tested this line three times, and each time it performs better than the last.

We’ve cooked everything from delicate scallops and omelets to boiling water for pasta, and every tester has noted how well it heats up, browning food perfectly which included leaving a great crust on seared steak. The handles are very ergonomic, though they can get a bit warm to the touch when over high heat. This cookware even survived our warp test—if you accidentally place a hot fry pan in cold water, it shouldn’t be damaged at all. A few times during testing, fond got a little too burnt-on which led to a few swipes with a steel wool, but overall, the set cleaned up nicely.

A few of us did find the pots to be a little unbalanced, with the weight focused on the center of the pot. We also repeatedly noticed that the set doesn’t stack easily for storage. Regardless, it’s a great set to have, with an 8-piece and a 12-piece version if you need more or less pans, all coming with a lifetime warranty.

Material: Stainless steel | Oven Safe Temperature: 500 degrees Fahrenheit | Induction Safe: Yes | Dishwasher Safe: Yes, but hand washing is recommended | What’s Included: 8-inch and 10-inch fry pans, 1.5-quart and 3-quart saucepans with lids, 3-quart braiser with lid, 6-quart sauce pot with lid

Best Design

Caraway Nonstick Ceramic Cookware Set

Caraway Ceramic Cookware Set
What We Like
  • Rounded interior for easy sautéing
  • Comes with storage
  • Even heat distribution
What We Don’t Like
  • Could use an additional small fry pan
  • Stainless handles can get hot

This 7-piece cookware set from direct-to-consumer brand Caraway is the perfect blend of performance and design. The selection is thoughtfully curated, and each set is available in a variety of stylish hues with a modern silhouette that looks great on any stovetop.

Every time we’ve tested this, Caraway proves that it is more than just a pretty cookware set. These pieces display controlled and even heat distribution, giving a subtle sear to meats and a gentle buildup of color on sauteed onions without scorching. In our tests, the nonstick surface demonstrates its ability to evenly cook eggs without sticking, and it also makes cleanup seamless each and every time. The pots and pans are generously sized and perfect for large-batch recipes, though we do wish there were one more small fry pan included for quick, small tasks. (You can get one separately, though.) The handles do get hot when in use, but that’s nothing an oven mitt or kitchen towel can’t help with.

Unlike other cookware sets on the market, this one comes with a magnetic pan rack and a canvas lid holder that can be attached to the inside of your cabinets for convenient storage. They are oven- and dishwasher-safe, although hand washing is recommended to keep them looking their best (most foods will glide off with a little soap and warm water).

Material: Ceramic-coated aluminum | Oven Safe Temperature: 550 degrees Fahrenheit | Induction Safe: Yes | Dishwasher Safe: Yes, but hand wash recommended | What’s Included: 10.5-inch fry pan, 3-quart saucepan with lid, 4.5-quart sauté pan with lid, 6.5-quart Dutch oven with lid, modular magnetic pan rack, canvas lid holder

Best Nonstick

Calphalon Signature Nonstick 10-Piece Cookware Set

Calphalon Signature Nonstick 10-Piece Cookware Set
What We Like
  • Quick to heat
  • Great temperature consistency and distribution
  • Easy to clean
What We Don’t Like
  • Food can get stuck on inside rivets

Made of hard-anodized aluminum (a process that makes it very durable), this Calphalon set has been one of our favorites for years. This 10-piece set is a bit pricey, but it has everything you need and, since it’s so durable, it’ll be years before the coating wears out. It’s tough enough that it’s safe for the rare metal utensil to be used while cooking.

Throughout our testing, we’ve been very impressed by how quickly this set heats up, and how evenly it distributes and retains that heat. The heavy-duty pans have a good thickness and weight to them, with one tester stating, “this feels like professional cookware.” We did notice some food getting caught around the interior rivets, but overall, the nonstick coating performs outstandingly and the cleanup was short and sweet. The extra-long stainless-steel handles can get hot to the touch, so be sure to use a mitt when cooking.

Material: Hard-anodized aluminum nonstick interior | Oven Safe Temperature: 500 degrees Fahrenheit | Induction Safe: No | Dishwasher Safe: Yes | What’s Included: 10-inch and 12-inch fry pan, 2-quart and 3-quart saucepan with lids, 3-quart sauté pan with lid, 8-quart stock pan with lid

Best Heavy Duty

All-Clad D5 Stainless Brushed 5-Ply Bonded Cookware Set

All-Clad D5 Stainless Brushed 5-Ply Bonded Cookware Set
What We Like
  • 5-ply construction gives incredible heat distribution
  • Very durable and high-quality construction
  • Oven safe to 600 degrees
What We Don’t Like
  • Handles may not be very comfortable for some

When it comes to high-quality cookware, All-Clad has built a reputation of trust among amateur and professional cooks alike. The d5 series is made of five alternating layers of stainless steel and aluminum for durability and optimum heat distribution and is built to last.

Our testing proved that these pans are excellent for high-heat cooking, like searing meats and sautéing vegetables. The thick construction does mean that it takes a few moments to heat up than thinner pots, the heat does eventually spread to the edges of the pan and provides steady, even heating during cooking. We did notice a bit of scorching while simmering tomato sauce and browning mirepoix, but gently stirring every so often should help avoid any hot spots as the pan heats up.

The unique handles stay cool, though some might find the groove slightly uncomfortable. You should also be aware that the 5-ply construction translates to heavier cookware. While this set is definitely not cheap, you get what you pay for with All-Clad—it’s a set of cookware you won’t have to replace for years, if ever.

Material: Stainless steel and aluminum | Oven Safe Temperature: 600 degrees Fahrenheit | Induction Safe: Yes | Dishwasher Safe: No | What’s Included: 8-inch and 10-inch fry pan, 1.5-quart and 3-quart saucepans with lids, 3-quart sauté pan with lid, 5.5-quart Dutch oven with lid

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *