Toaster vs. Toaster Oven: Which Should I Buy?

The Differences

Pop-up toasters generally weigh less than toaster ovens and take up less space on the counter or in a cupboard. Whether they have two or four slots, their ultra-hot elements quickly and evenly brown and crisp whatever you can fit in them. Even the fanciest toasters have just a few basic controls that make them family-friendly, from kids learning to make their own breakfast to parents fumbling for a bite before finishing their first cup of coffee. Most have a removable crumb tray that simplifies cleanup. Toasters usually cost less than toaster ovens.

Toaster ovens handle the same toasting jobs as pop-up models, but like full-size ovens, they direct heat onto bread placed flat on a rack. This expands their repertoire beyond unadorned slices thin enough to fit within fixed slots. Instead, you can toast handmade pastries, open-face melts, cheesy sandwiches, and more. Many models have the capacity and functionality to be rightfully called countertop ovens, stretching beyond toast, bake, and broil to include convection baking, air frying, and dehydrating. All these possibilities have their cost: toaster ovens are typically bigger, heavier, and more expensive than toasters.

The Tasks

Toast Pre-Sliced Bread

Winner: Toaster

With a pair of heating elements working in each slot, a pop-up toaster quickly and evenly crisps both sides of a slice of bread, making it the best choice for factory-sliced loaves and toaster pastries. A toaster oven usually performs the same job less consistently and more slowly. The distance between the toaster oven rack and elements, the heating speed, and how many slices you squeeze in all affect color and crispness.

Toast Home-Sliced Bread

Winner: Toaster Oven

Hand-cut slices of bakery or handmade loaves—including those baked in bread machines—can be thick and uneven. They also tend to have plenty of loose crumbs. Slices may be too long to fit in toaster slots or too small to easily pull from them. Even when hand-cut slices fit, large crumbs and broken corners can collect quickly in the bottom and burn if not cleaned out regularly. With a large, flat rack and wipe-clean interior, a toaster oven is better suited for slices from artisanal loaves.

Toast Bagels

Winner: Toaster

Modern toasters often have a bagel setting that turns on just one element. In slots wide enough to hold sliced bagels, English muffins, and maybe even rolls, a toaster fully cooks the interior without over-crisping the outer surface. A toaster oven can easily hold thick bread products on its rack, but it takes practice to get the rack height, temperature, and time just right to evenly brown a bagel’s cut side.

Defrost and Crisp Waffles

Winner: Toaster

Is a toaster or toaster oven better at defrosting and crisping precooked, frozen waffles? It is a close call, but the toaster wins because it hits the waffle with even heat from both sides, whereas a toaster oven could cook one side more quickly if you don’t nail the settings. That said, a waffle taken straight from the freezer may require two rounds in either appliance. Kellogg’s recommends toasting its frozen breakfast products twice on the lightest setting for a crisp outside and fluffy inside.1

Brown Baked Goods                                                           

Winner: Toaster Oven

Halved muffins, croissants, hot dog buns, and other baked goods may fit in a wide-slotted toaster, but likely in a tight squeeze with lots of flaky pastry or crumbs to clean up. A toaster oven is the best bet for oddly shaped baked goods, especially when warmed whole. Refrigerated pastries may warm better to the center on the oven’s bake setting, which sends more heat from the lower element, than on toast, which heats evenly from top and bottom.

Make Hot Sandwiches

Winner: Toaster Oven

With a slotted toaster, having sandwich fixings ready to pile on the moment hot toast slices pop up might let residual heat warm the filling, but it cannot match the heat of a toaster oven’s broiler. A toaster oven lets you build the sandwich and slide it in until all its layers meld into toasty, gooey perfection. Cheese caramelizes, nut butter roasts and softens, and marshmallows piled with chocolate on graham crackers puff and melt.

Make Breadcrumbs

Winner: It’s a tie!

Dry bread makes the best breadcrumbs, and toasting helps pull out the last bits of moisture. Whether you use a toaster or a toaster oven, the key is to get the bread as dry as possible without burning it. You will also need to watch more carefully than you would with fresh bread while processing the toast to ensure you end up with crumbs, not powder.

Toast Nuts

Winner: Toaster Oven

After bread products, the verb “toast” may most often be paired with nuts. A pop-up toaster cannot handle the loose pieces, but a toaster oven quickly roasts a few pine nuts for pesto, a handful of almonds to stir into oatmeal, or a couple of tablespoons of sesame seeds to sprinkle on chicken. When heating a full-size oven seems wasteful, a toaster oven can tackle other small-scale tasks, like roasting a head of garlic, crisping a batch of croutons, or dry-roasting whole spices.

Warm and Reheat Food

Winner: Toaster Oven

Reheated toast never impresses, leaving little call for pairing a slotted toaster with leftovers. A toaster oven is a different story. Its dry heat both warms and crisps mac and cheese, enchiladas, a slice of pizza, onion rings, and other leftovers that turn soggy in a microwave—and it does so faster than a full-size oven. The toaster oven has limits: Soups, stews, sauces, and dishes with a lot of liquid warm up best on a stovetop or in the microwave.

Should you buy a toaster or toaster oven?

When you just want evenly brown, consistently crisp toast, choose a pop-up toaster. One with wide slots will fit bagels and English muffins, and one with a lift boost makes hot slices easiest to remove. Choose a toaster oven when you also want to enjoy hot meals like toasted tuna melts and English muffin pizzas, as well as for toasting loose items like nuts and seeds.

If you have both, should you use a toaster or a toaster oven? Pull out the toaster for crisp, golden dry toast—and any other unadorned bread products that easily slide in and out of the slots. Pop bread with toppings or loose fillings and thick or gooey pastries into the toaster oven.